On the same day that he was awarded the Distinguished Service Cross for extraordinary valor in the European campaign during World War II, Sergeant Joe Dusak is charged with desertion during combat by a military court. Also summoned to testify are Corporal Crocker , Corporal Quinn and Private Pope, the only surviving members of a patrol led by Dusak. The charges stem from a patrol into the Black Forest of Germany in which Dusak claims the patrol got lost. Sergeant William Hutchins testifies that he ran into Dusak's patrol, and the men were laughing and not lost. In the end Dusak`s attorney manages to proof that the men were really lost and trying to avoid combat. It turns out that the actual culprits were Germans dressed as American GIs. The accused men did not reveal this information because of a lucrative secret deal...